What a Menu !. Our favorite restaurant in the city! Food is top notch. For an appetizer try the calamari. Lots of great choices for dinner; we like the Parmesan encrusted sole. No question...Coconut Cream pie for dessert. My wife and I go to Nick & Jimmy's when we want to treat ourselves. Service is excellent. We deserve it.
We love this place. We have loved this place since it opened, despite hearing friends speak less than entheusiastically about it. We have gone several times now, it is our go to place, and we have never had a bad experience. We ask for a certain waiter and she has been outstanding. Usually Jimmy is there. We find the food to be very good and have recommended the restaurant to many friends.
And to matters worse!.
Nick and Jimmy's has been very disappointing on several occasions. We will not go back.
We attend the Met Opera in HD showings at Century 24 on Saturdays, and get out around 3PM. We have tried Nick and Jimmy's twice now. The first time we thought maybe we just had an unfortunate experience. So a month later, we tried again. The pasta was covered with heavy oil, the filet tasted like tough chuck roast. The vegetables were not hot, and the frozen french fries were so over coooked that they would break when speared with a fork. The owner's daughter who was there that day was rude and stated if we like other restaurants in town we should go to them. Then later that day, while shopping for a new suit at a local men's store, I mentioned to a gathering of customers that we had been at Nick and Jimmy's and before I could tell my story, there was general agreement that customer's are often treated poorly there.
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Facebook to see what your friends are up to!